
A scientist returns from abroad with proof that a convicted man was innocent, but his revelation brings no relief to the family, only fresh suspicion
Dr. Arthur Calgary has been away on a long expedition. When he returns, he realises that he can provide an alibi for Jacko Argyle, who was convicted of killing his adoptive mother, Rachel, and who later died in prison. Calgary travels to the Argyle home to deliver what he expects will be welcome news. Instead, the family is horrified: if Jacko did not do it, then the killer must have been one of them.
Readers who like psychological mysteries more than detective puzzles, Christie fans looking beyond Poirot and Marple, and anyone interested in family dramas with secrets.
A standalone mystery about a large adopted family whose fragile peace is broken when a stranger proves the person blamed for a death could not have done it.
Mystery & Thriller · Wrongful conviction · Family secrets · Standalone
288 pages · ≈ 8 h
There is no famous detective here, and that suits the story. Calgary is an outsider who feels responsible for the damage his news has caused, and the book follows him as he tries to set things right. The real subject is the Argyle family: several adopted children, a distant father, a loyal housekeeper and a daughter-in-law, all forced to look at each other with new eyes.
Christie is interested in what suspicion does to people. Every family member has a reason to fear the truth, and the strain shows in quiet, sharp scenes. Rachel Argyle, the dead mother, emerges as a complex figure whose generosity was not always welcome. The solution is well hidden and fits the emotional logic of the book.
The pace is slower than in the detective novels, and the large cast takes some time to settle. The mood is more sombre than usual, though the violence stays offstage. Readers who enjoyed Five Little Pigs or Crooked House will find a similar interest in the long shadow of a single crime. It is a rewarding change of pace. About 288 pages in the William Morrow paperback.