
Ava falls for a mysterious man at a writing retreat in Italy where no one uses real names, then discovers back home how little they have in common
Ava is tired of online dating and decides to trust her instincts. At a writing retreat in Italy, where guests are forbidden to share real names or personal details, she meets a man known only as Dutch, and the attraction is immediate. It is the perfect romance. But when they return to London and real life, Ava discovers that she and Dutch have very different habits, families and ideas about how to live, and loving each other may not be enough.
Kinsella fans, readers who enjoy romantic comedies about real-life relationships, and anyone who has fallen for someone on holiday.
A warm romantic comedy about two people who fall in love on an Italian retreat without knowing anything about each other, then must face real life.
Romance · Romantic comedy · Holiday romance · Opposites attract
432 pages · ≈ 13 h
The premise is clever: instead of ending with the couple getting together, Kinsella starts with the perfect romance and then asks what happens next. The scenes back in London, as Ava and Dutch clash over pets, food, hobbies and friends, are often very funny and painfully recognisable. The retreat scenes are sunny and dreamy, and the sudden shift to rainy London is an effective comic contrast.
Ava is a likeable heroine, impulsive and big-hearted, and her devotion to her dog, Harold, is a running source of comedy. Her loyal, eccentric friends provide warmth and commentary. The book quietly asks whether love means changing your life or learning to share it, and its answer is sensible and kind. Dutch himself is more than a romantic prize; he has his own habits and loyalties, and the book takes care to show that his way of life has value too.
Some readers find the conflicts repetitive, and the misunderstandings rely on characters not talking openly. The Italian retreat section is short compared with the London chapters. As a gentle, funny and realistic romantic comedy, though, it is one of Kinsella's most charming recent novels. About 432 pages in the Dial Press hardcover; one library listing gives 416.