
When a famous Vermeer painting vanishes on its way to Chicago, two sixth graders follow a trail of coincidences, codes and puzzles to find it
Petra Andalee and Calder Pillay live on the same street in the Hyde Park neighborhood of Chicago and attend the same school, but they are not really friends. Petra wants to be a writer, and Calder carries a set of pentominoes, flat puzzle pieces he fiddles with when he thinks. Then their teacher, Ms. Hussey, starts asking unusual questions about art, and strange letters begin arriving around the neighborhood.
Curious middle-grade readers who love puzzles, art and codes, and anyone who enjoyed The Westing Game.
A clever, puzzle-filled mystery about two curious sixth graders who try to recover a stolen Vermeer painting in their Chicago neighborhood.
Children’s Books · Art mystery · Puzzles · Chicago
304 pages · ≈ 9 h
A painting by Johannes Vermeer, A Lady Writing, disappears while being transported to Chicago, and the thief sends letters to newspapers announcing that he will return it only if people look at art more honestly. Petra and Calder notice that odd coincidences keep connecting them to the case: a strange old book about unexplained events, a letter from Calder's friend Tommy written in code and pentomino shapes that keep turning up in unlikely places.
The book asks young readers to think about patterns, chance and the ways art can be questioned and debated, ideas that are rarely presented this seriously in children's mysteries. The friendship between the two heroes develops naturally, and Hyde Park with its university buildings and old bookshop makes a lovely setting. Brett Helquist's illustrations hide their own puzzle, which readers can solve alongside the story.
The plot depends heavily on coincidence by design, and some readers find the pace slow. But for thoughtful children it can be a doorway into art. Parents and teachers will find plenty to discuss afterward, from art history to probability, and later books continue the friendship. About 304 pages in the Scholastic paperback.